TSII: Crew Roster Talk – When Do You Stop?

Back from the little hiatus, time to get right back to it: Covering the Crew posted the latest full roster for the 2008-vintage Columbus Crew. You can check the post for names, details, plus more. I’ll steal his roster layout to frame the discussion, but I won’t borrow the commentary…that’ll come after the stuff I stole. Here goes:

Senior roster (17 of 18 slots filled)
Goalkeepers: Will Hesmer, Andy Gruenebaum.
Defenders: Frankie Hejduk, Chad Marshall, Danny O’Rourke, Ezra Hendrickson, Leonard Griffin, Andy Iro.
Midfielders: Brian Carroll, Duncan Oughton, Stefani Miglioranzi, Guillermo Barros Schelotto, Eddie Gaven.
Forwards: Alejandro Moreno, Nicolas Hernandez, Jason Garey, Brad Evans.

Developmental roster (10 of 10)
Goalkeeper: Kenny Schoeni.
Defenders: Andrew Peterson, Jed Zayner, Ryan Junge, Ryan Miller.
Midfielders: Robbie Rogers, Adam Moffat, Kevin Burns.
Forwards: Steven Lenhart, George Josten.

OK, so who’s new here? And I don’t promise a complete list, necessarily, but a useful approximation.

So, in defense, there’s Iro (and, maybe, Griffin), in midfield there’s Carroll – so that’s a rookie, basically, not a ton with which to get excited as yet – but smack in the middle of your “cheap talent” sits a nice up-n-comer in Rogers. At forward, you’ve got Lenhart and Josten – again, rookies – but a new brand-new joker popped into the deck when Hernandez came on board. Review it all and wrap it together, it’s basically a bunch of rookies, a wild-card player, and a defensive midfielder….a fizzling set of Saturdays throughout 2008 to be blunt about it.

That comparatively small haul is what that is. It may change before the season kicks off or it may not. But the real question in play is, when do you stop trying to add players in pre-season and start focusing on firing on as many cylinders as you’ve got in the regular season?

I’ll defer to long-time Crew fans on what all of us ought to expect between now and late, late March. But speaking as an outsider looking in, I have to wonder if the front office (that’s Brian Bliss now, right?) has a specific player in mind or just a set of positional criteria. My money is on the latter…for now…here’s to hoping for something better.

Based on this roster, however, what do I see the Crew doing in 2008? Missing the playoffs, sad to say. They need more people on the goal-scoring side of the ball. That, or rock-star-plus years for Gaven, Rogers, Garey…Josten…Hendrickson…hell, even Crew Cat if they’re going to make the post-season against a broadly improving East. I’m not saying it’s impossible. I’m just saying this isn’t papering out so hot…

3 Responses

  1. […] on March 8, 2008 by Jeff Lately, I’ve poked around the question of where I think both the Columbus Crew and Colorado Rapids are with regard to building their rosters for the 2008 season (hint: check the […]

  2. You’re missing two that haven’t officially been made part of the roster yet and are in contract negotions. Emmanuel Ekpo and Guilherme So.

  3. Thanks Barrak. Those two are acknowledged elsewhere, but I appreciate you completing the record for this post. I decided not to add them because they weren’t yet official…though, curiously, I had no such compunction about flagging Josten.

    I think it’s because I like the nickname I’ve given him: “Meet” George Josten (bah-NAH-nah-NAH-nah-NAH-nah-nah-nah-NAH).

    But, seriously, thanks.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: